An open letter to Todd Greenberg: - Bulldogs Army

Menu:

 
Let me preface this letter by saying I’m not calling for anyone’s head.

This is a letter of the heart.

I grew up in Kiama and now reside in Wollongong, yet the Canterbury Bankstown Bulldogs are my team. Why? Family.

My Nan was a Bulldog. She grew up in Enfield and lived in Greenacre until the day she died. She took her children and grandchildren to Belmore to watch the boys play. She was buried with blue and white flowers adorning her coffin.

Nan and I were very close. She was a kick arse woman who I miss dearly. When I go to games I feel close to her. On my way to the stadium I drive through the streets she used to walk down. I’ve never lived in the area, but when I’m there I think of her and I feel like a part of me is home.

I know she’d be proud of me for supporting her Bulldogs. If she were still here today I know she’d be sitting with us in the Army, swearing loudly and mispronouncing players’ names.

Family, though, is more than just bloodlines. I now have another family: the Bulldogs Army. It doesn’t matter who you are or where you come from; when you’re in the Army you’re united. You feel your spirits soar together after a win and you take the kick in the guts of a loss as one.

And the Bulldogs are our family. When we’re at a game we feel like we’re a part of something. No matter what’s going on in our lives, for 80 minutes a week it’s forgotten, and we’re right there with the 17 men on the field. They play for us and they play for each other. Family.

Except lately it doesn’t feel that way.

For reasons I can’t comprehend, it feels as though it all matters more to us than it does to the guys on the field. It feels as though all the heart and pride that came from being a Bulldog has been drained from our team.

Take St George for example: I used to feel indifferent toward them. They were just another opposition I wanted to beat. Then came round 10, 2009, Kogarah. Idris crossed the line in the dying minutes of an 80 minute arm wrestle. Looking around the ground, all I could see were blue and white people, jumping up and down and embracing. The players ran over in front of the Army and pumped their fists in the air. Pure elation.

Then it was taken away.

The video ref called no try and ripped our hearts out in the process. Ever since that day we have despised St George. They’re no longer a team we want to beat; they’re a team we want to demolish. St George robbed us of a win and stole our minor premiership. We’ve called for blood ever since. But where is our team?

They have not avenged this loss. In every game since we’ve effectively bent over for St George. Where’s the heart? Where’s the pride? Smashing St George means SO much to the Bulldogs fans. Why doesn’t the team understand this? Why don’t they feel the same way?

Is it because they don’t care? Is it because we’ve bought so many players since that they simply don’t get it because they weren’t there?

I spend a lot of my time talking Bulldogs with a lot of passionate supporters. The common theme arising from our conversations is that we can’t identify with our team anymore. The Bulldogs were once synonymous with aggression, pride and strength in the face of adversity. Steve Folkes spoke recently about the “us against the world” mentality. No matter what was thrown at us, both on-field and off, it couldn’t defeat us. Why? Because we were the Bulldogs: a successful team with a rich and proud history.

Oppositions feared playing us. They dreaded their upcoming games against us. Now I can only assume they look forward to the 2 competition points gifted to them.

I watch footage from old games and I can see the hunger to win oozing from the players. They ran hard, hit harder and backed each other. Their energy was contagious. I urge you to watch some of these old games and ask yourself, when was the last time you saw us play with that amount of heart and passion?

I understand the desire to recruit “nice guys”. We made the headlines for the wrong reasons and it cost us financially. We have sponsors to please and an image to sell, but how long can you maintain a happy sponsor relationship as their exposure dwindles due to an underachieving team?

I know you’re an astute leader, but you must never take for granted the willingness for people to part with their hard-earned for you. We battle the traffic, pay our $20 to park, pay to wear your merchandise, pay for our memberships or gate tickets, sit in the cold and then battle the traffic on the way home. At some point we have to ask, why bother for an insipid display from our team? Why spend money we worked hard for when the team gives the impression that it’s not appreciated?

At some point we lost our way. Perhaps the influx of new players meant that the Bulldogs mentality was never learnt. Yes, we need to maintain a healthy image, but not at the expense of passion. We need to find the balance between good guys off-field and passionate players on-field who can harness competitive nature and aggression and turn it into a weapon against our oppositions. This is what the fans are crying out for.

Our players need to know who we are and where we come from. They need to know who our greatest rivals are and why. They need to know what it means to be a Bulldog, what it meant to the past champions of our club and what it means to the supporters. They need to appreciate that it is a privilege to play for a club with such a rich and proud history, and for fans whose passion cannot be rivalled in the NRL. They need to know that they are playing for us and for their brothers on the field. For their family.

I write to you today to implore you to restore the Bulldogs culture. Our identity needs to be instilled in every player who walks out onto that field in the blue and white. Until this happens I fear it’ll be more of the same. 17 men dressed in blue and white, but no one wearing it.

Yours sincerely,

Anna Barwell

 


Comments

MG
07/07/2011 21:24

Great article...a pity Greenberg is too absorbed telling everybody how he has transformed the Bulldogs "brand" from negative equity to the position it is today...along the way killing our football culture and what it was to play for the Bulldogs.

Reply
Leon
08/07/2011 05:51

I couldn't of put it better myself. hopefully this letter reaches out to Todd and get acknowledged. bring back the old bulldogs!

Reply
Mark
08/07/2011 09:08

just brilliant

Reply
GD
08/07/2011 09:13

Outstanding read Anna *applauds* This reminded me of the great old days in my youth saving my allowance for the occasional day at Belmore S.G. Win or lose it was worth it because during the 80s-90s the team played with heart and tenacity.I also hope this gets to the board and T Greenburg.I love this club that much I spent $350 on a bulldogs tatt on my forearm recently as a 40th bday present to myself but more important i want to be able to tell myself that my tat was done during a dark patch the club is going through.I will support the dogs proudly through thick and thin.I hope the team finds its ticker soon.

Reply
danielle
08/07/2011 10:40

I just want to say magnificent Anna i was clapping all the way through the letter and cheering. Ive been a dog supporter for 31years and it breaks my heart to see the effort the boys are putting on the field u just want to go out there and slap them and tell them to wake up. The passing of the ball is shocking one out then run try spreading the ball a bit its not just the person who scores thats a hero its the hard work and effort put in by the boys to get the try. How about re grouping as a team with pride and family values and pull this side out of its current form and back into making it a side to recon with. Wearing blue and white is not something u get to just put on its hard work, dedication and loyalty that makes u a BULLDOG.

Reply
Bulldog in QLD
08/07/2011 10:53

Anna,

Once upon a time I looked forward to going to work every day and hanging out with “My Family”. Like most “doggie” fans I too have a story about where I come from. I worked for the Canterbury Bankstown Leagues Club in the 80’s during the tenure of Mortimer’s, Hughes’, “Robbo (The Animal)”, Terry Lamb and George Peponis.

These guys were GODS that adorned the entrance to the Club in one form or another. They were spoken about in the highest regard and respected by the fans for what joy they bought with them when ever they took the field.

The hunger you described is no longer there. We used to talk about roasting rabbits, cooking the chooks, extinguishing the fire breathing dragon, skinning eels, playing the toothless tigers but I digress.

Unfortunately for all of us rugby league is now a business, not the sport that it once was. The entire playing roster of any of our teams in the 80’s would have collectively received less money than one or two of our modern day players.

I too have lost my way with my much loved Bulldogs and have drifted away from the passion that I once had for MY TEAM and the sport in general. One can just hope that somewhere out there is the igniting spark that is needed to have us BELIEVING in our team again.

Thank you for sharing this article with us all.

Reply
Hairy
08/07/2011 12:54

Fair dinkum are you lot seriously still bitter about that minor premiership? I hope as much vitriol was directed at the peanut who made the interchange stuff up (costing you 2 points and the minor premiership) for the dogs earlier in that season.
Such short memories about getting your "hearts ripped out" at Kogarah. Or perhaps Anna is too young to remember a certain pass to Daryl Halligan in the 1998 semi finals?
That's footy - you win some, you lose some.
I applaud your passion regardless - the tribalism that clubs like the Dogs and the Dragons bring to league is priceless. And I think you have got a pretty good operator in Todd Greenberg running the show - your coach is another story...

Reply
CArey
08/07/2011 13:08

I believe theres too much off field responsibilities the players have taken on to help repair the bulldogs image so to speak. I mean its good to be noticed in the community, dont get me wrong, but maybe too much of it has made our team a bit soft....Look at the team we had to win the 2004 final, all trouble makers mind you but they had aggression and passion to go on and win after the disaster of the coffs harbour scandal. Maybe getting the players into lockdown and focus on their game rather than doin community work for sponsors will turn around our misfortunes

Reply
Shaun
08/07/2011 13:10

I too can very much simpathise with Anna's sendiments. I have lived in the Penrith district all my life - even played Harold Mathews, SG Ball etc for the Panthers. And although I have a huge soft spot for the Panthers - I am a Bulldogs fan (proven by me wearing Bulldogs attire to the game against the Panthers last weekend).

Reason? same as Anna - family. My father and his brothers all grew up in Bulldogs territory and being a Dogs supporter was drilled into me from a young age during the glory days of the 1980's.

To me, I see a team that is down on confidence that is playing without desire. It's not that they aren't trying or training hard but they appear to lack motivation and a WANT to go above and beyond.

Hope to see the boys turn it all around this weekend against the storm. Great letter Anna and Go the Mighty Bulldogs!!

Reply
Freddy
08/07/2011 14:12

Wow you just put in words everything I have been feeling all year. Perfect

Reply
Sue
08/07/2011 14:21

I agree. No passion at all. There is a video clip on the Bulldogs on website that shows this passion. Maybe it can be shown to the players so they get an idea of what it's all about.

Reply
Mr bulldog
08/07/2011 15:39

anna your a legend I'm so happy about your passion I'm a 30 yr old man that cries every time they lost but that was last year for some reason it's just does not feel like we are still supporting the. Same Bulldogs we used to
I would like to find out what kind of training does Kevin Moore do I'm sick of it I want the old bulldogs back
What kills on paper we got the best players in the comp come to the field it's like they never opted Footy the only one in the team that's got passion is micheal ennis he is born to be a bulldog
I just hope they get it together before it's too late

Reply
KiwiBulldog
08/07/2011 17:23

Awesome Anna!

Reply
Alec
08/07/2011 17:27

The Club Is Hurting , The Fans , The Board Members , The Players . No one wants Canterbury not competing for the Title year in year out But sometimes things do not go the way we want them to , But you can be sure of one thing and that is that We Will get through this stutter and become a Powerhouse yet again in Rugby League.
The Club has a Chairman in Mr Ray Dib and a Board that is committed to make Canterbury a Powerhouse .

Reply
mick
08/07/2011 17:39

good one anna this is all true i have been following the dogs for 38 years and its not the same.i think annas letter should not only go to todd greenberg it should go to the board and every bulldog player to show how much support is out there these players should have there heads down after reading this letter,start playing as a team or you will loose a lot of support from us or find another club we have juniors comming through the ranks that are ready to jump in your spot ..

Reply
Bob
08/07/2011 17:46

Anna, I grew up in Bankstown and have beewn a loyal Berries to Bulldog supporter for over 70 years.
I have loved my team through thick and thin but I like you am worried about the lack of passion in the team at the minute.
The continual inside pass back to a lumbering forward just astounds me.
The only spark we have is from Menace and Barba so without them where would we be.
Living in Brisbane I only get to watch games on the Idiot box but it seems to me that some of our top players have been around one season too long and may it is time to give the good players in the reserves a go.
As much as I hate to say it maybe Sterlo is right when he says "If you're good enough you are old enough".
Lets give the kids ago they cannot be any more dispirited than the First graders are right now.

Reply
Sean
08/07/2011 17:58

What a fantastic heartfelt letter. It is nice to know there are others that feel the same as I do. I've stopped putting my Bulldogs jumper on when the game is played, and if the first try is scored against us I turn off the tele, coz I know the ticker isn't there like it used to be. Bring the players through the juniors again, they have ownwership and the desire to play first grade for the Might of the Blue and White, bnot the paypacket snd the nice car they can get from it by turning up.

Reply
Trev
08/07/2011 17:59

Well said Anne.

I think after we lost The General and Hazem I have not felt the same connection with my team. I was born in Greenacre and my whole family follows the dogs, it is in my blood and it hurts to see the lack of passion for the jersey.

I am currently living and working full time in the Philippines, I am a member of the club and I do everything I can to watch my team each and every week. I have not only paid for the membership, and my gear but I fork out for an online membership to livenrl so that I don't miss a game.

I think Todd has done an amazing job with the club off the field, but I honestly think its time we find some guys who will understand what it is to be a Bulldog on the field.

I want to be able to look at the scoreboard when we are 16 points down with 11 minutes to go and know that we are still are strong chance of winning that game.

Go The Dogs

Reply
John
08/07/2011 18:16

Anna i congratualte you on making your thoughts known but you haven't gone far enough. What about our coach and his staff are they of NRL standard? What about our board and Todd are they up to the task of making the hard decisions for the sake of the club putting friendships aside? I can't answer yes to either of those questions. We have got the players to compete for the title, i mean Moore has made sure of this as he has purchased two teams in three years which in itself is a disgrace. He out of all of us should know to invest in our kids and bring them through not buy rejects from other teams. So if Moore has purchased two teams in three years, we have a top 4 roster, where lies the problems of the past 18 months? You guessed it, the coach. Unfortunately as i stated before the board and Todd along with Kev and his staff are all too buddy buddy to make the right decisions for the clubs sake.

Reply
Andy
08/07/2011 18:23

Thank you for writing that. We all feel the same way!!

Reply
Jason
08/07/2011 18:25

It's just not the same anymore, ever since i was little i have been a true dogs supporter, the passion by the players was relentless. The bulldogs used to play passion, now its just for the money. The only true dog is Ennis. The rest of the boys need to step up. I used to rip on my mates every time the sharks lost against them(I'm a shire boy) now i fear i will have to endure the shame of losing to such a mediocre team. The boys need to rise together and show the spirit we once had, or premierships won't be won and such a great and enthusiastic fan base may dwindle.

Reply
BULLDOG FAN 4 LIFE (PETER)
08/07/2011 18:30

Just briliant , could not have said it better, there is no pride in that blue and white jersy, a true bulldog player wears his hart on his sleeve , but lately this is not the case, i take my 4 boys to all games , but recently i just cant , my 4 year old asked me dad why the bulldogs dont win anymore ? i could not answer that ? we need to have the old bulldogs back, need to have that passion, pride back in the team without this the bulldogs name is nothing

Reply
Sharon
08/07/2011 18:32

Well said Anna. You hit the right buttons.

Reply
Scott
08/07/2011 18:37

well said Anna.I've also watched dvds of the 80,84,85,88,95,04 grand finals and the defence just isn't as good as it was in those matches

Reply
Siobhan Penney
08/07/2011 18:40

that was a fantastic letter we as BULLDOGS FANS we all feel the pain each and every week when we see our boys either performing on the field or not it is very disheartening to see that our BLUE AND WHITE falling apart therefore our fans are feeling the pain and before u know it they will turn there backs on a great team like our BLUE AND WHITE we are all family and we don't want too see our boys fall apart at the clubs expense BULLDOGS FOR LIFE i know we can pick up the pieces and move forward

Reply
Henry
08/07/2011 18:45

Get Kevin Moore to read that letter to the players before they run out against the storm tomorrow if it doesnt work then we got a long few years ahead.....

Reply
Mona
08/07/2011 18:55

thanks anna you've all got our full support and you've put all of our feelings out there i kust hope they can sack that idiot kevin moore before he further destroys us

Reply
Claire
08/07/2011 18:57

Anna,
What a fantastic letter,you have articulated how most if not all Bulldogs fans feel, its not that we are giving up on our boys, its that they are giving up on us. I hope that every one of the players reads your heart felt letter and takes a moment to think about the way they are playing and how we as a "Family" can be Proud to be a Bulldog again.

Reply
Belmore Boy
08/07/2011 19:07

In other words not explained clearly BRING BACK THE BAD BOYZ!!!!! This is Rugby League not Tennis!

Reply
Sean Burke
08/07/2011 19:13

I feel we haven' had a genuine Bulldogs team since 2004.It's all well and good having all these ambassadors for good behavior off the field but the way these guys over the last 6 or 7 years just give up after the first bit of adversity is a disgrace.The Bulldogs teams of the last 40 years would never give up like these puppies do and it's embarrassing to watch.Show some pride and respect what the blue and white jersey represents aggressive defence,spirited attack and never giving up till the final whistle blows.

Reply
Jackie Baxter
08/07/2011 19:41

Well said Anna... I to am a proud berries/bulldogs supporter... I grew up in Padstow and my brother was ball boying for the dogs during the Malcolm Cliff coaching days... use to love going to Belmore to watch the games....I even went to school with Kevin Moore..... I think since we lost Steve Price we havent been the same team.... The players we have need to step up or go and find a real job in life ... the coach cant play the game for the team....I think its time we started using our Reserve graders and under 20's and start dropping some of the lime lighters and see how they like playing on grounds that have big divets and in front of crowds of about 500 people

Reply
Daniel
08/07/2011 19:48

Anna,

Thankyou for your heart felt letter. I am a 30 year strong Bulldogs member and fan. Passion is lacking, that is clear. Soft is not a word i speak of relating to our performances, until now. I dislike the current theme of coach bashing in he media. I feel that Kevin is an integral part of the recipe needed to restore faith in the jersey. Why? Because he is one of the strongest links to a bygone era. The legacy of 'Bullfrog' lives on through Kevin, and this must inspire all who have a connection with the club and are all proud of the efforts of the Moore family to build this club into a powerful entity. Look back at Bullfrog's reign, all the great moments through this time. Let that be a start of the passion that we should all feel for the Bulldogs.

Kevin can tell them and show them what to do, but he can't do it for them. that's when passion is required.

The NRL has changed from these times though. It is now a business, and as such are the players just going to work and ' going through the motions?' To put it another way, you wont see too many " hazem El Maseri's " Playing a massive career and holding many records with the one club. do players in the top grade remember what is was that got them interested in the greatest game? I believe that the Harold Mathews and S G ball players live and breath passion and loyality. They WANT to play for the Bulldogs and imagine this - they are not paid vast sums of money to put their bodies on the line. - inspiring. When was the last time a first grader went to watch an SG Ball match and cheer these guys on??

Professional athletes? Please.
Maybe these guys need to get a real job the way it used to be, work all week, train in the evening and play your guts out of a weekend. Win loose or draw, shake hands, grab a beer and share war stories at the bar with the opposition.

Andrew Ryan, the Garboligist?

Ban Barba the Bricklayer?

Steve Turner the Forklift driver?

The current players should ask the legends of the club how things used to be done.

I will always support them however some things need to change. We are all part of this team and we all need to display our passion at the game regardless of the current form or media speculation. So stand tall, stand proud cheer loudly and scream our lungs out to let everyone know who we are and where we come from.

Reply
BRONCO
08/07/2011 20:05

BRONCOS '2011'

Reply
BooHoo
08/07/2011 20:05

Myth is what your club is, bought not breed, cheating salary cap, fans causing issue's, You are where you belong....

Reply
Noah
08/07/2011 20:06

Anna i couldnt be more proud of you. Youve told it exactly how it is an explained what every dogs fan is going through. Surely they will get the message now....

Reply
Robert Taylor
08/07/2011 20:06

Anna, i wrote to Todd a few weeks back, his secretary replied, we are not going back to Belmore, i said if a team has no home it has no heart, your letter summed that up perfectly.
This team needs a good lesson in passion, they have none, we may have a team of players sucessful at other clubs, but you cannot buy the Bulldog spirit.
We need a tribal home, we dont need an empty stadium, back to belmore, back to our home.
Regards. Robert

Reply
Danielle
08/07/2011 20:06

I am a proud Doggies supporter and have been since I can remember all my family's support the Dogs.
Last year I bought my first membership and would drive a 10 hours return trip to Sydney just to watch the boys play.
Unfortuantely I couldnt bare to do this again this year to go all that way to watch the boys loose, time and time again it seemed they really had no passion or care but were just there collecting their pay check ever week.
You BUY players and of course they will not have heart for their club like us the supporters! We need to bring our juniors through!
Great read Anna you explain it exactly how most of us are feeling. Brings a tear to me eye!

Reply
bill
08/07/2011 20:07

I think its simple, the whole team needs to start playing as a professional football team with the aggression and never say die attitude that once saw them gain the respect of many people. What happened to the big hits, pressure on oppenents, good kicking game and the magic attack, morriss has gone to sleep, the halves are playing so poorly that they need to be dropped to herald mathews and the forwards are running backwards like a big girls in mini skirts they have no go forward or direction. It seems to me that the only players having a go are Ben Barba, Turner and Jamal Idris the rest are useless. Morris played good only in the first game against the tigers when he scored that 90 metre try after that he dissappeared never heard of the guy ever since hes gone to sleep. Mick Ennis the Penis is not running out of dummy half gaining those important metres laying the foundation for the backs and does not have any support what soever, as the for the forwards lol its a joke where do i start, Bob Cat Ryan leave and dont look back you have lost all your skills and strength you should be an orange peeler. Pritchard makes 2 good runs then throws in the towel like a girl, Tolman not to bad.

Reply
boohoo
08/07/2011 20:30

Danielle are you proud when your club causes issue within the NRL, fans been idiots, salary cap cheats, are you proud that instead of promoting junior you go out trying to buy a premiership

Reply
bill
08/07/2011 20:31

David Stagg hahah, mate hes only good for a stag nothing else, i have never really seen him do anything good, Eastwood lol please the guy is over weight and has no offloading skills nor can he put on any big hits why bother with getting him from England doesnt make sense, i remember him saying he was home sick, mate i think he is sick in the head. Ben Roberts lol useless honestly thank god hes leaving like Mat Utai did. I honestly cant understand how Hodkinson and Keating are first grade players they both should play netball, If Morris doesnt want to have go send him to join his brother at St.George. Where is the protection for Barba the legend, his mates arnt protecting him enough thats why his dropping the ball, other teams have figured him out under the high ball or grubbers. I dont think it is Kevin Moore's fault that the team is losing, because Kevin can coach them in the best way but at the end of the day its up to the players to produce what they are trained to do. At the moment non of them are having a go and look like they dont want to be there. I just wish we could have the 2004 team again that was the best side ever the bulldogs have fielded since lambs days. Imagine this team is put together again. Patten (fullback) Elmasri and Lolesi (Wings), Tonga and Maitua (Centres), Anasta (five eighth), Thurston (Half back), Perry (dummy half), Grimaldi (Lock), Asotasi and Sonny Bill (Second row), Mason and Omeley (Front row) what a team.

Reply
john
08/07/2011 20:39

Well written Anna nothing else needs to be said as a bulldog supporter who started school with Kevin 40 years ago yes i remember when as the berries not a tough team to the rename as the Bulldogs came the passion and toughness and results, players wanted to be at Belmore now we are exactly as Anna described. We as supporters demand the DOGS OF WAR to return.

Reply
Mick
08/07/2011 20:43

Anna is spot on...! I have followed the dogs since 1974 and this is the best side that does nothing I have seen..... We could have come last with out the cost...! Kev is a nice guy but not a coach, possibly even worse the Fulton was...! Newcastle has not half the stars but they have a go.....

Reply
dave the toad - storm fan
08/07/2011 21:01

wow. if your team had half your heart they would be lethal. you don't need to fire up on on Saturday against the storm though. give em a week to let it sink in.

Reply
Get over It
08/07/2011 21:20

Get over it the fact you lost a game 2 seasons ago against the Dragons.

Reply
joseph.b
08/07/2011 21:24

That was very passionate and i do agree that the team must think of the fans.ihave only been intersted in them for 2 years and they have let me down. i am thinking of the 2004 grand final how the side played with pride and passion and also listened to the screeming crowd who were saying go DOGGIES!!!!
that is a team that can take interest and the family slowly builds and we will win for the fans.
i am an 8 year old boy writing this in hope that they can turn on and play like the team we want that has what it takes to win a grand final for the 9th time!!!!!!

Reply
Ura Whinger
08/07/2011 21:32

You forgot to mention Canterbury were salary cap cheats.
Play football, stop signing no hopers, stop whinging about losing a game 2 years ago to Saints.GET OVER IT. Dogs have had their fair share of bounce of the ball calls. a grand final win against Manly comes to mind - watch it and you will see why.
the best thing this season would to see Parra or Roosters finish with the wooden spoon. Second best thing would be Canterbury winning the wooden spoon... again.

Reply
Fan since '82
08/07/2011 21:34

Anna your right....and Todd you'd do well to listen to what the fans are saying!

There is no spirit left in the team. There are one or two players that really give it a good shake each week but that's it. I, as a long time supporter, don't mind losing the occasional game PROVIDED the team played their guts out.

Todd we're tired of it. We don't need blaitant examples (like when Ma$on was laughing under the goal posts) to know that the current team has no 'get up and go'. We see it in the slumpped shoulders, downward cast eyes, the often boring and frequently ineffective game play....not to mention the general lack of enthusiasm all round.

Every fan will tell you that they can physically see when the players "lift". You see it with other teams when they score a try...or after a dust up....or even after a half time pep talk. We can SEE it and WE RESPOND by cheering louder than before, sitting on the edge of our seats. We feel the energy and the passion from the players and we support them with every fiber of our souls.... because we know they are busting their guts out there!

....such a shame we rarely see it thesedays!

Todd...anyone...give the dogs fans reason to cheer again.

Reply
nic from the fern
08/07/2011 22:16

well said anna!!! couldnt have said it better myself. a few weeks ago i saw two instances in the bulldogs v tigers clash that eppitomised where the bullbogs culture is atm.
after repeated efforts by the bulldogs against a seriously below par tigers outfit, to score the opening try in particular a couple bombed trys by our "marquee" signing frank pritchard, we finally got over the line, as a result of poor defence and plenty of posession. frank pritchard, the eventual try scorer, who only had to run about 10yards and fall over the tryline, gave off a cocky little smile to the fans as though he had just accomplished any other nrl player could have, with his eyes closed. i looked at his expression of accomplishment and pride and couldnt appreciate or relate with that look on his face.
then midway through the second half, a sorry effort by fullback wade mckinnon, saw him knock on the kick and our center josh morris picked up the ball and fell over the tryline. it was probably the easiest and almost pathetic try ever scored in the tough town of campbeltown, and yet josh decided to throw his arms out and do the airoplane. there was nothing i repeat NOTHING synonimous about that act with the bulldogs jumper. lets get one thing straight if your jarred hayne and you been 9 players with 5mins to go and turn the game on its head by scoring a try, by all means pull out a classic celebration. but it seems these players have put toughness on the backburner for good tv pictures.
i in no means wish to single any player out and blame nobody in particular. but from the top all the way to the players on the feild weve lost the idea of what we the bulldogs are about.
we are not about selling tickets and celebrating trys for the camera. we are about tough defence, keeping our head down and rolling sleaves up, working harder than the others and being modest in success. we are not about buying big name superstars over youth and home grown talent. we are the bulldogs and until we get back to being the bulldogs, i watch with little interest.

Reply
brett
08/07/2011 22:40

Anna,
I'm a Manly fan but your words are music to my ears. Unfortuantely we live in the world ruled by the almighty dollar. No longer is our teams built on local juniors those who grew up playing in the local comp dreaming and hoping to be graded and be priviledged to wear out teams colours. Yes Todd is a great leader and have had the pleasure to listen to him at a corporate function lets hope he listens to you.

Reply
Craig of China
08/07/2011 23:24

What a brilliant letter. I could not agree more. I grew up in Liverpool and always followed the Dogs. My grandparents were dyed in the wool Parramatta fans...and how sweet it was to smash the Eels!
I moved to Singapore for 3 years and now live in China, and still check results and updates every week, but agree that sadly the team isnt the same.
We all know the Mortimers, the Lambs, the Hughes, the Price's, the Ryans, the Pattens, the El Masri's etc have to move on sometime....but we need the guts, the hunger, the bite and the mercy that comes with being blue and white.
As the letter said, we got smashed on the salary cap issue, but we stood firm, took all the crap and came back...but now we need the heart again.
C'Mon Dogs...your'e better than this. Kevin Moore is a good man, and a true blue dog, but one man doesnt manke a team !

Reply
George
08/07/2011 23:26

I feel the same. Weel said George

Reply
Mario
08/07/2011 23:28

Well said Anna.

Reply
Nathan
08/07/2011 23:51

We need Belmore back. Simple as that.

Reply
juzzi
08/07/2011 23:58

anna great letter hopefully the playyers and the doggies club can read this and embrace this letter... :)

Reply
marty
09/07/2011 00:25

Anna i think your letter is spot on the money,i grew up in manly and have supported the bulldogs since an early age.All my family support manly and i wonder at the moment why dont i ,but the truth is i will allways support the doggies but they have to have pride in the jumper.

Reply
Jenny1966
09/07/2011 01:02

great letter Anna. Strong feelings shared by many bulldogs fans. A Wollongong based supporter since 1966 who loved it when we beat the dragons and felt it deeply the day we were robbed that you quoted in your letter.. A regional member and very disappointed with the performance. Bring back the passion of Mortimer,johns and lamb days.Todd you need to donwhatever it takes.there are plenty of upset fans out there...

Reply
09/07/2011 01:34

How cares about the bulldogs,how about you fans clean up the stupid arabs that bring down your club and maybe the team will become the club that it use to be in the 80's.

Reply
09/07/2011 01:41

The bulldogs last two grand final victories where controversial in 1995 and 2004.In 95 7th tackle try to win the game and not to mention the extra player on the field,2004 minichiello's try that was disallowed when it was a try which would made the score 13 to 6 and the bulldogs complain about the ref's mistakes.

Reply
Carla
09/07/2011 05:56

bring back BELMORE! Awesome Anna.

Reply
Ali
09/07/2011 09:03

Top read Anna and agreed 100%. I believe it all changed when it went from ARL to NRL .. it became about how much $ they could make a year and seeing which team
offered better and moving on. The scandals started and then the loyalty died. Gone are the days when I was a little girl and would look out my window and see the Bulldogs players run down my street emptying our bins .. Part of their exercise and community work combined. There's still a glimmer of hope that things will go back to how they used to be.. Until then my passion is gone. Once again Kudos to you Anna.

Reply
VAI
09/07/2011 16:09

The nice guy recruitment is inaccurate, otherwise we would not have been so successful in 2009. The answers are elsewhere and when a club has to come from the depths of our 2008, it is often not going to be a quick recovery, ala 2009. I actually covered this on The Kennel in response to your concerns in a thread you created on this there, i'm surprised you missed it and continued with this along the lines of the nice guy recruitment policy. It's incorrect. The rest of the letter is good however. :)

Reply
tim
09/07/2011 20:14

Let me start by saying I'm a manly fan but I needed to read this because as much I love to watch manly beat the dogs its not a fight any more. I love the hard 80min arm wrestles, I hope you can bring it back soon.

Reply
lesley meredith
10/07/2011 00:13

anna congratulations for saying it as it is no passion no pride.please dogs turn it around show us we are wrong.i have followed you for 40yrs and i will keep supporting you but please show some heart.

Reply
AJ
10/07/2011 12:46

If you had won the last game against the Tigers you would have won the minor premiership. Saints didn't rob you of it, at worst the referee did but you had your chance vs the tigers and blew it!

Besides, would you have wanted to play Parra in their form? You would have been out sooner than you were!

Reply



Leave a Reply